PDA

View Full Version : Manatee "Reclassification" Decision Postponed


seagrant
09-12-2007, 10:42 PM
With all the interest in the Florida Manatee in this forum I thought you all might be interested in this:

If any of you have been following the forum posts on the status of the Florida Manatee you know that even after a recent record number of deaths impacting the manatee population in Florida a proposal was made to down-list the manatee's endangered status to just "threatened". This was due to a re-wording of the criteria for listing of endangered species at the state level and not due to any real sustainable recovery of the manatee.

Many of us wrote letters to then Gov. Jeb Bush.

I was concerned and am still very concerned that our new Republican Gov. Charlie Crist would, well I'll just say not look after the manatee's interests.

I don't know if this "postponement" is good or bad but I look at it as a bit of a good sign. It shows Gov. Crist is acting responsibly (or passing the buck, whatever....); but the manatee has been granted a little more time before the final decision at state level is made on its listing under the endangered species act as "endangered" or "threatened". The listing to "threatened" was pretty far along but this postponement might be a ray of hope.

Down-listing the manatee from endangered to threatened at state level would almost surely result in less protection measures being put in place even when more and more threats are mounting in their environment. And as I've stated before Florida is the guardian of the population of the manatee for the entire country. Florida must act responsibly in this matter and not be swayed by large moneyed boating and development interests.

I sincerely hope this extra time is a good thing and there is still time for anyone who wants to weigh in on the matter to do so. There are many ways of doing this and I think our letters/emails to the governors surely did some sort of good.

Here is a statement of the "postponement":

September 12, 2007
FWC postpones vote on manatee management plan, reclassification

The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) postponed a decision Wednesday to adopt a new management plan and two rules to reclassify manatees from endangered to threatened.

Commissioners had planned to take final action on the proposals during their Sept. 12 session, but Gov. Charlie Crist, in a Sept. 10 letter to FWC Chairman Rodney Barreto, asked for the postponement. Crist expressed concern that three FWC commissioners have just begun their terms and may need more time to evaluate manatee issues.

"ll get with the governor and address his concerns" Barreto said.

New commissioners Dwight Stephenson, Ron Bergeron and Kenneth Wright said they will make every effort to be prepared to vote on the issue by the FWCs December meeting in Key Largo.


Here is an example of what we need to protect, taken by myself Feb 07:

http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c17/seagrant/Manatee_8Feb07005_webxx-1.jpg

Jonathan Bird
09-13-2007, 12:43 AM
Thanks for bringing this important issue to our attention. Might I suggest that as a service to people who want to help, post a short letter we can use as a starting point for letters to the governor, and a litle of anyone who should receive such a letter with address. We can all easily copy and paste, tweat it to our personal taste and mail.

Jonathan

seagrant
09-13-2007, 02:44 AM
OK Jonathan,

I'll reply with something right after this.

Here is some data from Gov. Charlie Crist's letter requesting postponement on Sept 11th:

I have to say that Gov. Charlie Crist is showing a bit of "moxie"........ and kudos to him for now lets see how it plays out (actually we won't just see we will take action). The "boater's rights" and development lobbies that are for less manatee protection are very powerful though.

Here is his letter requesting the postponement from Sept 11th (quotes from):

Crist asks FWC to postpone manatee decisions

Gov. Charlie Crist’s request that the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) postpone action on major manatee issues will get serious consideration when the FWC convenes Wednesday morning.
“This is important to the governor, so I am going to recommend to the other commissioners that we defer action on these matters,” FWC Chairman Rodney Barreto said. “However, we probably will have people who travel to St. Petersburg for the meeting to offer public comments, so will accommodate them.”
Specifically, the FWC’s agenda for the three-day meeting includes adoption of a new management plan for manatees and rule proposals to reclassify the species from endangered to threatened.
In a Sept. 10 letter to FWC Chairman Rodney Barreto, Crist applauded the agency’s efforts to implement a strong, thorough management plan for manatees. However, the governor expressed concern about current methods of estimating manatee populations and the record number of manatee deaths in 2006. Crist asked the FWC to postpone the manatee items on the agenda -- to give new commissioners more time to evaluate the complex issue “of such gravity.”
Two FWC commissioners will be attending their first FWC meeting and a third commissioner will be attending his second meeting. The FWC has seven commissioners.
The FWC meeting will convene at 8:30 a.m. all three days. The complete agenda is available at MyFWC.com under “Commission Meetings.”

seagrant
09-13-2007, 03:06 AM
Allrighty Jonathan had a good suggestion regarding me posting data on how and who to email/write to.

It is late here but I want to get some data out so here is a start, it may be missing a few contacts but I feel if you write/email the governor the communication does trickle down...

The fastest way is actually to use the link and form here on the Save the Manatee Club site - it goes to three recipients the Gov, Interior Secretary and Director United States Fish and Wildlife Service. It takes about one minute to read and send:
http://www.savethemanatee.org/actionalert.cfm?id=14

Here is an example of my email/letter to Governer Jeb Bush in January 2006 - it is not a "cut and paste" type letter. I wrote it specifically to not look like a form letter:

Plus there are some links in this other forum post with lots of data on how this downlisting issue came to pass.
http://wetpixel.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=11851&hl=


Quote from my January 2006 other forum post:

"I just thought everyone might like to see a "sample" email just in case anyone is thinking of sending one.....hint.....hint. I was going to use the quick "form" one on the Save the Manatee site, but decided to put one in my own words. Note Jeb Bush has stated that the Florida Manatee is "my favorite mammal".

Here it is (minus my add & phone at end):

Mr Jeb Bush,

I support more protection for our Florida Manatee, not less by "downlisting" it to "threatened" instead of "endangered" as the new criteria state. The new "endangered" criteria are "just a change in wording", but words that could result in significant loopholes and less protection for our favorite marine mammal, the Florida Manatee.

As a NOAA Scientific Diver, AAUS Florida Aquarium Diver, surveyor on REEF's Advanced Assessment Team (scientific fish surveys for organizations including the Park Service) and member of our Marine Mammal Stranding Network, I see the direct consequences of careless and thoughtless actions of humans impacting creatures of the sea. I have snorkeled with hundreds of manatee and even had the "chance" manatee encounters while swimming in the Keys or shore-diving at Boca Grande. They are the most amazing marine mammals, so curious and gentle in their nature, also very sensitive and tactile, we humans could sure learn a lot from them, my experiences and my underwater photographs of them are most profound!!!

I love boating in our Florida waters and frankly I have never been on a boat that hit a manatee or even witnessed a boat striking a manatee? It must be pretty careless boaters who do that? Thus I do agree that we need more (not less) slow speed zones for manatee, the propeller and boat motor damage to two-thirds of our adult manatee is plainly evident when seeing these sweet creatures and frankly is so pointless to have this happening to such a docile creature.

Also maybe it would be a good idea again to look at more education for boaters? Possibly even in the form of a "boater's license" required to drive a boat. Then things like looking for manatee signs and areas to stay away from could be part of the boat driver licensing process. I know this would not be popular, but then it was not popular to support drunk driving legislation, but absolutely necessary when so many lives are lost. Manatee have lives also, and a right to live and not constantly face pointless injury.

And I am concerned that so much of the Florida Manatee's habitat is being developed, e.g., Three Sister's Spring, Crystal River, one of the largest winter gathering places for manatee in the state. How could this happen that the state didn't keep that land in trust for the manatee and our children?

I trust that you as the Florida Governor are going to set a good example to Florida and the rest of the nation and support actions to further help the "endangered" Florida Manatee and not let some "re-wording" of the criteria set the stage for a decline in their population and quality of life. We are the world's guardian of this sub-species of the West Indian Manatee and we need to do all we can to protect them.

Respectfully and Sincerely,
Carol Grant"

I got fairly quick response back on this communication.

Here are some addresses/emails:

Florida Governer Charlie Crist
email: Charlie.Crist@MyFlorida.com

Mailing Address
Office of Governor Charlie Crist
State of Florida
PL-05 The Capitol
Tallahassee, FL 32399-0001

I'll add some more addresses tomorrow, its a bit too late now and I'm fading. But it is a start.

Regards, Carol

seagrant
09-13-2007, 03:26 AM
OK one more thing before I crash,

Here is the actual letter from the governer. Besides writing/emailing him contacting all on his cc: list would be a good way to go. I'll get looking for their contact info tomorrow:

http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c17/seagrant/GovLetter.jpg

Jonathan Bird
09-26-2007, 03:38 PM
Carol,
Thanks for posting this stuff. I'm going to send a letter and e-mail using your suggestions, and I hope others will too. Anyone that has ever interacted with manatees will certainly understand why they are so important to protect. They are the most harmless, friendly and wonderful animals--it would be a shame to lose them over something as stupid as people needing to drive boats quickly through their habitat. I'm all for driving fast, but there are appropriate places for this to happen.

Jonathan